• All Posts
  • Race Reports
  • Gear
  • About Me
Adirondack Runner
Contact me

Choosing Midweight Trail Runners

7/3/2013

3 Comments

 
Picture
I've been thinking of getting a new pair of mid-weight trail runners for a while now. I'm currently running trails in a lightweight racer (La Sportiva Helios) or a heavy max-cushioned tank (Hoka Mafate), with nothing in between that I really like.

I ordered five pairs in the 10-11oz range that I've heard good things about, and tested them today on the treadmill at Keene Fitness. They were, in descending order of weight (top left to bottom right in the photo): Pearl Izumi Trail N2, North Face Ultra Guide, North Face Hypertrack Guide, Asics Fuji Trainer, and Asics Fuji Racer.

I wasn't fond of the feel of either of the North Face shoes, which for my stride felt very clunky in the transition strike to toe-off, and the Fuji Trainers didn't fit my heel well at all. Those three shoes were out pretty much the instant I stepped on the treadmill--they'll go back to Running Warehouse for sure.

The Trail N2s and Fuji Racers, on the other hand, felt right immediately. The Pearl Izumis are the clear winners for what I'm looking for (mid-weight, plenty of cushioning, specifically for ultras), so I'll keep those--in fact, I ran 5 miles on the trail with them later in the day; I'm committed. I'm torn on the Fuji Racers. They are very light (9.5oz in size 10.5), so they compete with the La Sportiva Helios as my fast racing shoe. I had planned to buy another pair of Helios, but the Fuji seems like more shoe (better rock plate, stiffer forefoot) for the same weight. I'll need to compare them side by side with the Helios before I decide whether or not to keep them as my lightweight racer of choice.

3 Comments
Derrick link
7/3/2013 09:32:10 am

Tough to beat the Helios!

Reply
Jan
7/3/2013 11:04:59 am

Very true! The Helios is certainly the best choice for wet, slippery conditions and very technical trails--I doubt the Asics can touch it there.

I do sometimes wish the Helios was better at preventing a stubbed toe or stopping me from feeling those big pebbles that I land on in just the wrong spot, so that's where I see the Asics being a good choice. But I won't know for sure until I try them.

Reply
Derrick Spafford link
7/4/2013 02:54:55 am

True. Just debating on which shoes to wear at Wakely, but probably going with Crosslites to be safe...and protect my achilles injury a bit more.




Leave a Reply.

    My Best Results:

    7/31/16: Escarpment Trail Run 18mi
         1st place, 3:01:12
    7/18/15: Wakely Dam 33mi
         1st place, 4:45:01, Course Record
    6/21/14: Manitou's Revenge 54mi
         1st place, 10:50:34, Course Record
    4/21/14: Boston Marathon
         2:55:52
    10/13/13: Mohawk Hudson Marathon
         11th place, 2:49:49
    9/29/13: Vermont 50
         3rd place, 6:40:29
    5/25/13: Patch Sprint 12.5mi
         1st place, 2:01:43, Course Record

    Categories

    All
    About Me
    Gear
    Race Reports
    Training Log
    Training Tips
    Videos
    Weekly Recap
    Whiteface Skyrunning

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.